16 Sep, 16:11
Betting on Gold ETF Recovery Post-FOMC
Bullish-3.11%
AI Summary
The author plans to trade a short-term rebound in gold and equities following the FOMC rate hike, betting on easing interest rate pressure.
For this FOMC meeting, I am more inclined to prepare for a trade where interest rate pressure eases after the hike is priced in, allowing gold to strengthen again. The prerequisite is confirmation from the bond market first.
As clearly stated in my weekly report: a 25bp hike followed by observation is my baseline. While we should remain cautious about another hike in December, I do not yet have sufficient evidence to make sustained hikes the baseline scenario. By the time of the meeting, the market has already priced in this hike at nearly 90%. Continuing to bet on the hike itself offers limited expected alpha; it is whether there will be further tightening that determines how far this trade can go.
This is also what I believe is the most easily overlooked aspect tonight: the Fed raising rates does not preclude bonds from rising. If the market had previously worried that the Fed was lagging behind inflation and willing to take action, this could actually alleviate the inflation risk premium demanded by long-end bonds. At the same time, as long as the dot plot and press conference do not push future rates above the path already priced in by the market, there is room for front-end tightening expectations to unwind. These two logics can occur simultaneously but must be verified separately; one cannot see the 10Y yield drop and immediately declare that the market is trading in a rate cut.
After the Fed began hiking in 2004, long-end yields continued to decline for a period; similarly, the year following the first hike in 2015 saw a significant rise in US Treasuries. These historical reminders tell me that policy rates and market rates move at different paces. They do not prove that a top will definitely be seen tonight, nor can they compress months of market action into a single candlestick chart at 2 AM. The backgrounds regarding growth, inflation, and capital flows were also different back then.
What I need to observe tonight is: after the Fed formally delivers on tightening, whether the market is still willing to continue selling bonds.
On the dot plot, 3.9% and 4.1% for the end of this year are two intuitive reference points. If this hike brings rates to 3.75%β4.00%, a median forecast of ~3.9% for year-end would correspond to no net hikes within the year; ~4.1% would imply one more 25bp hike. However, since the market is already hedging against a second hike, 4.1% cannot automatically be equated with an unexpectedly hawkish stance. I am more concerned with the column for 2027: whether further space for future rate cuts is being removed, and whether the press conference supports the market pushing out the duration of high rates.
A scenario that might form a "pain trade" is when the hike lands, but the subsequent path is not as high as the market feared, causing yields to spike and then fall back. In such a case, shorts and hedges made based on higher rate assumptions may need adjustment. Here, I am betting on the divergence in expectations. Whether this evolves into a short squeeze must be proven by price; one cannot directly use high probability of aggressive hikes as evidence of crowded short positions.
However, while the Fed can influence inflation expectations, it cannot solve oil supply issues. This is another reason why I will not heavily bet on rates peaking based solely on one hike. As long as oil prices and fuel costs continue to rise, the market may still increase its assessment of persistent inflation. A more comfortable setup would be for bonds to stop falling after the Fed delivers on tightening, followed by failed breakthroughs in oil prices. When improved policy credibility coincides with eased energy pressures, a continuation of declining rates becomes more likely.
In this path, I prioritize watching gold. I need to see the dollar and real rates stop rising, gold stop making new lows in response to rate hike news, and subsequently reclaim the pre-meeting consolidation range, with support holding on pullbacks. A decline in nominal yields alone is not enough: if inflation expectations fall faster, real rates may still rise, and gold may not receive support.
For trading, I will initially use GLD or call spreads with a defined maximum loss to trade a repair over the next 1β10 trading days. Confirmed pullbacks serve as entry observation points. The first target is the upper edge of the previous consolidation range, followed by prior highs; if the confirmed low is broken again, I will exit. Without confirmation, the position size is zero. There is no need to go all-in prematurely, nor to guess every adjective used in the press conference.
On the equity side, do not chase shorts simply because of the rate hike. Easing interest rate pressure and stable credit conditions are sufficient to bring rebounds to QQQ, real estate, and some financing-sensitive sectors. However, my skepticism regarding AI capital returns does not disappear here; while the industrial logic may remain bearish, short-term trades must respect the rebound driven by falling rates. When bad news hits but prices fail to drop, existing shorts must reassess risks.
My conditions for admitting error are also clear: if the dot plot and press conference continue to push the market to revise up the rate path, if 2Y and 10Y real yields continue to rise, if the dollar strengthens, and if gold confirms a breakdown of its lows; or if oil prices continue to break out and credit begins to deteriorate. Upon seeing these signals, I will withdraw the "easing interest rate pressure" trade and will not use historical analogies to psychologically comfort myself against losses.
My baseline remains one hike followed by observation. If bonds stop falling and gold stops falling after the hike tonight, I will take this signal seriously. The actual position will be added only after prices stabilize post-press conference.